New Rochelle's neighborhood pizzeria

New Rochelle pizza.
Made right.

New York pizza, Italian favorites, heroes, pasta, and catering—made with quality ingredients and served with the friendly care of a family-owned shop.

Order Online View Menu Call (914) 636-0800

Get directions →624 Main St, New Rochelle

Today's hoursMon–Sat 11–10 · Sun 11–9

Start your order →Pickup, delivery & catering

4 delicious specials

Feed the whole family.

Choose a Cestra’s Pizza 4 bundle and call to order.

Special with large pizza, wings, mozzarella sticks, garlic knots and soda

Large pie, garlic knots & 2-liter soda

$19.95

Large pie, penne vodka, garlic knots & 2-liter soda

$25.96

Large pie, wings, garlic knots & 2-liter soda

$25.95

Large pie, mozzarella sticks, wings, garlic knots & 2-liter soda

$32.95

Prices are plus tax. Minimum order required for delivery; delivery charges may apply.

Call (914) 636-0800 to Order Order Online

Catering & big orders

Pizza & Italian catering in New Rochelle, NY.

Feeding an office, school event, hospital team, party, or family gathering? Cestra's Pizza 4 can help with crowd-friendly pizza, wings, pasta, chicken dishes, salads, heroes, and more.

Office lunches & meetings

Schools & team events

Parties & celebrations

Family gatherings

Explore Catering Call (914) 636-0800

What we do best

More than just pizza.

From a classic New York slice to full Italian dinners, everything is prepared for the way you want to eat—quick lunch, family dinner, or a table full of guests.

Cestra's specialty pizza — Specialty pizza

Fresh Cestra's hero sandwich — Hot heroes

Baked pasta with melted cheese and tomato sauce — Baked pasta

Chicken Marsala with mushrooms — Chicken Marsala

Shrimp entrée in a light sauce — Shrimp entrées

Chicken Parmesan served with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella — Chicken Parmesan

Fresh Margherita pizza with mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil — Margherita pizza

Grilled chicken wrap served with dressing — Grilled chicken wrap

Golden mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce — Mozzarella sticks

Real food photographed at Cestra's Pizza 4.

New York Pizza

Classic cheese, grandma, Sicilian, and specialty pies baked hot with a crisp, golden crust.

Italian Favorites

Heroes, pasta, wraps, chicken dishes, salads, and plenty more beyond the pizza counter.

Catering

Trays and crowd favorites for offices, schools, family gatherings, and celebrations.

Family owned

Your neighborhood spot.

Cestra's Pizza 4 is proud to serve New Rochelle and the surrounding community with fresh food and friendly service. We believe great food starts with quality ingredients—and that a neighborhood pizzeria should make every customer feel welcome.

Stop in for a quick slice, pick up dinner for the family, or let us help feed your next gathering.

Ready when you are

Your next favorite meal is a tap away.

See Menu & Order

New Rochelle pizza.Made right.